Skip til indhold
Få vores nyhedsbrev
Da En
  • Udgivelser
  • Medarbejdere
  • Undersøgelser i gang
  • Temaer
  • Om VIVE
  • Nyheder
  • Arrangementer
  • Projektforløb
  • Centre og netværk
  • Kontakt
  • Presse
  • Vi tilbyder
Da / En
Tilmeld nyhedsbrev
Del
Videnskabelig artikel, ­3. juli 2018

Randomised controlled trials in Scandinavian educational research

Indtil 2011 var der få randomiserede, kontrollerede studier inden for uddannelsesforskning i Skandinavien. Herefter har der været en forøgelse i antallet af forsøg, hvoraf det største antal foretaget i Danmark. Finansiering og koordinering fra regeringen er ofte afgørende for implementering af randomiserede, kontrollerede studier, og de er sandsynligvis vigtigere i små lande som de skandinaviske lande.

Maiken Pontoppidan , Maria Keilow , Jens Dietrichson , Oddny Judith Solheim , Vibeke Opheim , Stefan Gustafson & Simon Calmar Andersen
Folkeskole, Uddannelse
Hent den videnskabelige artikel

+ tilhørende materialer

Background

The Scandinavian countries have a long history of implementing social interventions, but the interventions have not been examined using randomised controlled trials until relatively recently compared to countries like the United Kingdom and the United States.

Purpose

The purpose of this paper is to examine the history of randomised controlled trials in Scandinavian compulsory schools (grades 0–10). Specifically, we investigate drivers and barriers for randomised controlled trials in educational research and the differences between the three Scandinavian countries Denmark, Norway, and Sweden.

Methods

To locate relevant trials, we performed a systematic search of four bibliographic databases and a search for grey literature. Results were combined with trials located through direct contact with researchers and government officials. A trial was included if one or more interventions were randomly assigned to groups of students and carried out in a school setting with the primary aim of improving the academic performance of children in grades 0–10 in Denmark, Norway, or Sweden. We included both conducted and ongoing trials. Publications that seemed relevant were screened based on full-text versions. Data extraction included information from included studies on grade level, study period, sample size (N), project owner, funding source, and theme. In addition, we conducted two semi-structured interviews by phone or in person with central employees in funding agencies and ministries and nine mail correspondences with researchers and policy makers.

Findings and conclusion

RCTs in grades 0–10 were few in all of Scandinavia until about 2011, after which there was an increase in all three countries, although at different rates. The largest number of trials has been conducted in Denmark, and the increase is more marked in Denmark and Norway compared to Sweden. International trends towards more impact evaluations and results from international comparisons such as PISA have likely affected the development in all countries, but while many trials in Denmark and Norway are the result of policy initiatives, all trials in Sweden are initiated by researchers. We believe the lack of government initiatives to promote RCTs in Sweden is the most likely explanation for the differences across the Scandinavian countries. Funding and coordination from the government are often crucial for the implementation of RCTs and are likely more important in smaller countries such as the Scandinavian. Supporting institutions have now been established in all three countries, and we believe that the use of RCTs in Scandinavian educational research is likely to continue.

Læs også
  1. Videnskabelig artikel

    The social class gap in bachelor’s and master’s completion: university dropout in times of educational expansion

  2. Undersøgelse i gang

    Evaluering af indsats til at styrke ordblindes læsning og stavning

  3. Nyhed

    Webinar: Hvad er erfaringerne med mellemformer mellem almen- og specialundervisning?

  4. Rapport

    Læringsfællesskab er lykkedes i Rødovre Kommune

  5. Rapport

    Støtte, støttebehov og elevresultater

  6. Rapport

    Ramme for opgørelse og sammenligning af udgifter til specialundervisning og inklusionsunderstøttende indsatser

  7. Rapport

    Casestudier af kapacitetsopbygning gennem specialpædagogisk sparring og samarbejde på almenskoler.

  8. Nyhed

    Styring, organisering og faglig praksis

  9. Videnshæfte

    Læs om Mellemformer – en kombination af almen- og specialundervisning

  10. Nyhed

    Kortlægning af mellemformer

Tilmeld nyhedsbrev
Del

Tlf: 44 45 55 00

Mail: vive@vive.dk

EAN: 5798000354845

CVR: 23 15 51 17

KontaktPresseJob i VIVETilgængelighedserklæring

VIVE – Det Nationale Forsknings- og Analysecenter for Velfærd leverer viden, der bidrager til at udvikle velfærdssamfundet og til at styrke kvalitetsudvikling, effektivisering og styring i den offentlige sektor både i kommuner, regioner og nationalt.

Vores nyeste viden i din indbakke hver uge.

Tilmeld nyhedsbrev
Følg os