Does risk-adjusted payment influence primary care providers’ decision on where to set up practices?

Background

Providing equal access to healthcare is an important objective in most health care systems. It is especially pertinent in systems like the Swedish primary care market, where private providers are free to establish themselves in any part of the country. To improve equity in access to care, 15 out 21 county councils in Sweden have implemented risk-adjusted capitation based on the Care Need Index, which increases capitation to primary care centers with a large share of patients with unfavorable socioeconomic and demographic characteristics. Our aim is to estimate the effects of using care-need adjusted capitation on the supply of private primary care centers.Method: We use a dataset that combines information on all primary care centers in Sweden during 2005–2013,the payment system and other conditions for establishing new primary care centers used in the county councils, anddemographic, geographic, and socioeconomic variables for low-level geographic areas. To estimate the effectsof care-need adjusted capitation, we use difference-in-differences models, contrasting the development over time between areas with and without risk-adjusted capitation, and with high and low Care Need Index values.

Results

Risk-adjusted capitation significantly increases the number of private primary care centers in areas with relatively high Care Need Index values. The adjustment results in a changed distribution of private centers within county councils; the total number of private centers does not increase in county councils using care-need adjusted capitation. The effects are furthermore increasing over the first three years after the implementation of such capitation,and concentrated to the lower and middle range of the group of areas with high index values.

Conclusions

Risk-adjusted capitation based on the Care Need Index increases the supply of private primarycare centers in areas with unfavorable socioeconomic and demographic characteristics. More generally, this result indicates that risk-adjusted capitation can significantly affect private providers’ establishment decisions.